Introducing

Robert Brusca

Robert A. Brusca is Chief Economist of Fact and Opinion Economics, a consulting firm he founded in Manhattan. He has been an economist on Wall Street for over 25 years. He has visited central banking and large institutional clients in over 30 countries in his career as an economist. Mr. Brusca was a Divisional Research Chief at the Federal Reserve Bank of NY (Chief of the International Financial markets Division), a Fed Watcher at Irving Trust and Chief Economist at Nikko Securities International. He is widely quoted and appears in various media. Mr. Brusca holds an MA and Ph.D. in economics from Michigan State University and a BA in Economics from the University of Michigan. His research pursues his strong interests in non aligned policy economics as well as international economics. FAO Economics’ research targets investors to assist them in making better investment decisions in stocks, bonds and in a variety of international assets. The company does not manage money and has no conflicts in giving economic advice.

Publications by Robert Brusca

Europe| Sep 13 2023
Industrial Output in EMU Falls in July; Capital Goods and Consumer Durables Output Drop
Industrial output and manufacturing output as well as sector detail for the European Monetary Union in July revealing drop in overall output and in manufacturing output, spurred by sharp declines in consumer durables and capital goods output weakness. Consumer nondurables show an increase in output of 0.4% in July while intermediate goods output is higher by 0.2% month-to-month in July. There is minor growth month-to-month in intermediate goods and nondurable goods, but that fails to offset the sharp drops in consumer durables and capital goods output.

Sequential trends are not reassuring Sequential growth rates from 12-months to six-months to three-months show manufacturing output falling by 1.7% over 12 months, falling at a 6.2% annual rate over six months, and falling at a 4.4% annual rate over three months. Output falls over each of these horizons, but it's not getting progressively worse although it still falls faster over three months than it does over 12 months. Consumer goods output follows this same pattern with the declines on all three horizons and no sign of progressive deterioration but still with output over three months weaker than the output decline over 12 months. Within consumer goods, however, consumer durables output shows progressive deterioration with a drop of 6.9% over 12 months bested by a drop at an 8.7% annual rate over six months that then worsens to -14% at an annual rate over three months. In contrast, consumer nondurables output also declines on all three horizons but falls at just a 0.5% annual rate over 12 months, then declines much more sharply at a 6.9% annual rate over six months but then trims its fall to just a 0.4% annual rate over three months - slightly less then its pace of decline over 12 months. Intermediate goods output falls on all horizons, but the drops become progressively smaller as there's a 5% drop over 12 months, a 2.8% annual rate drop over six months, and a 1.6% annual rate drop over three months. Capital goods output shows an increase year-over-year, but that gives way to progressive deterioration in growth rates as its 2.6% output gain over 12 months collapses to a 5.4% annual rate decline over six months, and that worsens to a 7.7% annual rate decline over three months.

Quarter-to-date growth On a quarter-to-date basis (July relative to the Q2 average for output) overall production and output in manufacturing drop at annualized rates of 5% and 8.5%, respectively. Declines occur in each of the sectors and in each of the consumer goods subsectors. The sharpest decline in output in the quarter is from consumer durable goods, declining at a 15.9% annual rate; that drop is followed closely by a decline at a 14.7% annual rate in capital goods output.

Output compared to its pre-Covid level Taking a longer perspective… looking at output compared to where it was in January 2020 before COVID struck, both manufacturing and industrial output are higher on balance by 1% for overall output and by 1.3% for manufacturing output. Consumer goods output is higher by 6% on that comparison, consumer nondurables output is higher by 6.1%, and capital goods output is higher by 6.7%. However, consumer durable goods output is lower by 2.3% and intermediate goods output is lower by 4.5% on that timeline.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Global| Sep 12 2023
ZEW Survey in September Shows Broad Weakening in Germany, U.S., and EMU
Most responses in this new survey for the euro area, Germany, and the United States show weakening month-to-month. Ten of the observations weaken month-to-month while six show strengthening. The variables that strengthened month-to-month were the assessment of the U.S. economic situation, economic expectations in Germany, and stock market expectations in the euro area, Germany, and the U.S. On the foreign exchange side, the dollar is expected to strengthen vs. the euro. We continue to see a weaker economic situation signaled in the euro area and in Germany. Economic expectations for the U.S. are weaker as economic expectations for Germany strengthen. The ZEW respondents are optimistic regarding inflation as they see it getting weaker in all three areas. As a result of this, short-term rate expectations are weaker in the euro area as well as in the U.S. Long-term interest rate expectations are weaker in Germany and in the U.S. And given that optimism on inflation behaving and interest rates falling, stock market expectations are stronger in all three areas.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Europe| Sep 11 2023
Industrial Sector in EMU and Europe Is Mixed in July
Output in the European Monetary Union in July remains a mixed phenomenon. Among the thirteen early reporters of industrial production, six of them show output declines in July, after ten of them had declined in June and five of them declined in May. Over the last three months there has not been a majority of countries showing output declines across all three months but there certainly is a critical mass of countries showing declines and a good deal of unevenness in output in the European Monetary Union. Out of 39 months-to-month changes (13 countries over 3-months), 21 of them showed declines (53.8%). In July among the four largest economies (Germany, Italy, France, and Spain), three of them showed output declines; similarly, 3 of the largest economies posted declines in June; however, in May, all four of the largest monetary union economies logged increases in output.

Sequential patterns: 12-months to 6-months to 3-months Sequential patterns in output are mixed. But looking at the diffusion index for the European Monetary Union overall in manufacturing, the three-month reading is below the six-month reading and the six-month reading is below the 12-month reading. The overarching view from the manufacturing PMI statistics is that there is ongoing weakness in the monetary union. Austria, Germany, Finland, Ireland, and Sweden (the latter not a monetary union member) each show declines in output over three months, six months and 12 months. The median for the monetary union overall shows a 2.1% decline over 12 months; output declines at a sharper 3.6% pace annualized over six months; that decline trims to a decline at a 1.3% annual rate over three months. The lesser decline in output over three months has a lot to do with a sharp 10.7% increase in output from Portugal, a 6.7% increase over three months in Spain, a 5.1% increase in the Netherlands, a 4.8% increase in Italy, and a 3.6% annual rate increase in France. Over three months there clearly is a collection of countries showing considerable strength. However, over three months Germany also shows a 9.5% annual rate decline, Austria logs a 7.9% annual rate decline, and some of the smaller countries post substantial negative numbers for output as well. Sweden, not a European Monetary Union member, logs a decline in output at a 12.6% annual rate over three months. Clearly, the monetary union and Europe are looking at relatively mixed conditions.

Accelerating output trends are weak but improving We also calculate in the table the tendencies for output to accelerate in the euro area on a month-to-month basis; 53.8% of countries show accelerating output in July compared to June. However, in June only 7.7% accelerated relative to May. In May 61.5% of the respondents showed output accelerated relative to April. Over three months 45.5% of the countries are showing output accelerated relative to six-months; over six months only 38.5% are accelerating relative to 12-months and over 12 months only 27.3% are accelerating compared to one year ago. The sequential growth rates on acceleration show that acceleration is a phenomenon that occurs in fewer than 50% of the respondents over each horizon (from 3- to 6-months and from 6- to 12-months). However, the proportion of firms experiencing acceleration has been steadily increasing; over three months at 45.5% the proportion is getting much closer to the neutral mark at 50%.

Quarter-to-date With July data, we have the first monthly observation in the third quarter. Quarter-to-date calculations look at the growth in July compounded over the second quarter average. The median for output in the second quarter in the monetary union is a decline of 3.2%; eight EMU member countries show negative numbers for output in the incipient third quarter with one-month’s data in hand.

IP growth rate rankings Ranking the year-over-year growth rates for industrial production on data back to mid-2006, only two countries in the table have a rank standing above their historic median growth rate over this span. France has a 77-percentile standing, and Malta has a 55-percentile standing. However, among the other large EMU member countries, Germany has a 25.4 percentile standing, Italy has a 32.7 percentile standing, and Spain comes close to having a median standing at the 49.8% mark. The median standing across all EMU members is much weaker at 23.4%.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Japan| Sep 08 2023
Japan’s Economy Watchers Index and Outlook Weaken
Japan's economy watchers index slipped to 53.6 in August from 54.4 in July. It's a small slip that still leaves the index with a very high queue standing at its 92nd percentile. The index is lower on balance over three-months, but it's higher over six months and higher by 8.1 points over 12 months. The month-to-month setback seems to be something of minor importance…but momentum is waning.

The future index also slipped back to 51.4 in August from 54.1 in July. That index has a queue standing at its 75.9 percentile, still a firm-to-strong standing but not as strong as the current index. The future index is also weaker over three months and slightly stronger over six months and stronger over 12 months as well, but by just a small amount.

Current index While the current index is lower on the month and it is a minor setback, all components were lower month-to-month except for retailing. There was substantial breadth to the step back in August small though it may be. Many components still have extremely strong rankings. For example, the household sector, retailing, eating & drinking establishments, and services all have queue percentile standings above the 90th percentile. A substantial portion of the economy is still quite strong nonmanufacturers as a group have an 86.6 percentile standing. However, housing has a below-median 39-percentile standing, corporations taken as a whole have a 78-percentile standing, manufacturers have a 64-percentile standing, employment overall has a 55.7 percentile standing not far above its historic median as the median occurs at a rank standing at the 50th percentile.

Future index The future index shows weakness across the board with the headline and all components weaker in August than they were in July. The headline weakens and shows weaker components across the board for three months. Over six months three measures show declines: eating & drinking places, housing, and employment. The rankings in the future survey are generally strong but not as strong as for the current index. The future headline has a 75.9 percentile standing, households, retailing, eating & drinking places, and services all have rankings in their 80th percentile. Housing has the weakest standing at a 37.9 percentile, employment is below its median at a 47.4 percentile standing, corporations is at its 66.4 percentile, manufacturers are at their 60th percentile and nonmanufacturers overall are at their 76th percentile.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Germany| Sep 07 2023
German IP Falls in July
Industrial production in Germany fell again in July, although the pace of decline let up from June. Industrial production fell by 0.8% in July following a 1.4% decline in June and a 0.1% decline in May; industrial production has fallen for three months in a row and in four of the last five months. Manufacturing output accelerated its decline, falling by 1.8% in July after falling by 0.9% in June. Manufacturing production had risen by 0.2% in May.

All three major sectors showed declines in output in July with consumer goods output falling by 1%, capital goods output falling by 2.9%, and intermediate goods output falling by 0.7%. This compares to June when only capital goods output fell, dropping by 3.3% while consumer goods output increased by 2.2% and immediate goods output edged ahead by 0.3%.

Sequentially, however, output continues to weaken as the 12-month growth rate is -2.2%, the six-month pace is -5.4% and the 3-month pace is -9.1%. Manufacturing mimics these declines with a 1.5% decline in output over 12 months, a 4.5% annual rate decline over six months, and a 9.5% annual rate decline over three months.

The construction sector drops in July, but it's sequential output path shows the deteriorating trend with construction output rising 0.8% over 12 months, falling at a 1.2% annual rate over six months and accelerating the decline to -3.5% annually over three months. Overall industry, manufacturing, and construction, deliver declining trends and declining trends that accelerate.

Real manufacturing orders and real sales in manufacturing both fell in July. Real sales fell for the second consecutive month-to-month decline; however, both real manufacturing orders and real sales show positive growth and a pickup over three months compared to six months, failing to echo the accelerating downtrend that we see for output overall and for manufacturing and construction in the industrial production report.

Industrial indicators for Germany show greater weakness in July compared to June for the ZEW current index, the IFO manufacturing index, IFO manufacturing expectations, and the EU Commission industrial index. The industrial indicators do not echo the decelerating trend from 12-months to six-months to three-months that we see for industrial output. However, each of these manufacturing measures is weaker over three months than it was over six months, indicating a greater move towards weakness over the last half year or so although not stretching the trend back to 12-months.

There are some early output data available for Portugal and Norway in July. Portugal shows output increase in July while Norway shows a decline. Norway shows industrial output falling in June; however, both Portugal and Norway demonstrate output declines over 12 months and worse declines over six months. But that trend transitions into growth over three months. Portugal shows output growing at a 10.7% annual rate over three months while Norway barely eeks out any gains at all rising at a 0.3% annual rate.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Germany| Sep 06 2023
German Orders: What Turns Up…Must Turn Down
German orders turned sharply lower in July, falling by 11.7% month-to-month after rising strongly by 7.6% in June and by 6.2% in May. The sharp decline in July still does not turn the three-month growth rate negative. However, it sharply blunts what had been an incipient upturn and severely recasts the outlook for German manufacturing which for the past few months was seeming to have inexplicably brightened, whereas now it appears that May and June may have simply been a couple of rogue months of strength in an ongoing period of weakness.

Foreign vs. domestic trends Foreign orders in Germany fell by 12.9% in July after rising 11.9% in June and 6.8% in May. That series still carries a positive 17.5% annual rate of growth over three months. Domestic orders fell by 9.7% month-to-month in July after gaining 1.5% in June and 5.3% in May. For domestic orders, the three-month growth rate is a clear negative growth rate of 13.1%, at an annual rate. Over three months domestic and foreign orders are each moving rapidly and in opposite directions – that won’t last.

Sequential trends Sequential growth for German orders shows negative growth rates over 12 months and six months with those headline declines interrupted by a +3.8% annual growth rate over three months. That 3.8% gain is looking less authentic. It is out of context sequentially and strongly blunted in backtracking in monthly data. Foreign orders post a -11.1% annual rate over 12 months and a -12.5% annual rate over six months but grow at a strong +17.5% annual rate over three months. However, that three month-growth rate is severely crimped by the sharp downturn in July; it's extremely hard to understand what trend is really in play here for foreign orders in Germany. German domestic orders fall 9.8% over 12 months, followed by a 9.5% annual rate decline over six months, in turn, followed by a 13.1% annual rate drop over three months. The negative growth rates for domestic orders are persistent.

Quarter-to-date (QTD) orders In the quarter-to-date, because of the severe weakness in July, which starts the new quarter, we are looking at negative growth rates of 23% to 36% for total orders, foreign orders, and domestic orders in the newly started third quarter.

Real sales by sector Real sector sales for Germany show declines in July as sector sales in all the categories in June as well as in July; that compares to increases in all the categories but one in May. Even so, real sector sales growth in manufacturing is up by 1.4% over 12 months, flat over six months, and up at a 4.1% annual rate over three months. Consumer goods show negative growth rates over 12 months, six months, and three months. Capital goods show positive growth rates of 7.9% over 12 months, 2.3% over six months, and at a 12.1% annual rate over three months, demonstrating consistent growth and even acceleration on the three-month horizon. Capital goods manage to do this with the two most recent months showing significant drops in real sales- that undermines the trend. Intermediate goods show sales falling by 5.2% over 12 months, falling at a 1.4% annual rate over six months, and falling at a 3.3% annual rate over three months. Overall, the sales numbers generate positive gains over three months, but the sequential growth rates are not compelling – nor is the sector detail.

QTD trends broadly weak In the quarter-to-date calculus for the first month in the new quarter, there are negative growth rates across the board for all the categories of sales: headline sales, and manufacturing sales, both fall at a 4.6% annual rate. In the new quarter, the deepest decline is from consumer durables at a -20.9% annual rate.

EU Commission indexes show euro-weakness The EU Commission industrial confidence reading for Germany, France, Italy, and Spain shows negative readings for all four of those countries in July as well as in June and May. There is no hint of the German mid-year strength in orders. The industrial monthly changes on these metrics in June show deterioration for all countries on all horizons except for France; it registers a slightly less negative number in June compared to May, but then the French industrial metric posts a large negative reading for July. The industrial indexes in Germany, France, Italy, and Spain show worsening from 12-months to six-months to three-months for all four countries. The current queue standings for the industrial confidence measures for the four countries show the strongest readings for Italy and Spain with queue percentile standings in the lower 30th percentiles. Germany, and France post even weaker queue percentile standings in their 26th to 27th percentiles. All of these are weak readings.

Since Covid struck... Taking a longer perspective, looking at all the variables in the table compared to where they were in January 2020, before COVID struck, everything is weaker than its January 2020 level except for capital goods shipments; they are stronger by 4.2%. Total orders are lower by 8.4%, real sector sales and manufacturing are lower by 1.8%, and the EU industrial confidence indexes are lower by 1 to 2½ points in Germany and Italy and lower by about eight points in France and lower by 12.6 points in Spain.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Global| Sep 05 2023
Composite PMIs Fade in August
The global total, or composite, PMI readings from S&P for August saw the slippage with both the average and the median readings for this group falling to lower levels in August compared to July after the average and median each had slipped in July relative to June.

Among the 25 jurisdictional readings in August, 19 of them show lower values in August compared to July, while 21 of them had shown lower values in July compared to June, and in June 21 of them showed lower values compared to May. There's a clear slowing going on based on aggregating individual results.

In August, 16 jurisdictions had diffusion readings below 50. In July, there were 19. Both months represent a sharp erosion from June when only five showed readings below 50. In diffusion terms, the reading of 50 is the line of demarcation between output increasing or decreasing.

Sequential readings over three months show 9 jurisdictions with average readings below 50, over six month 6 readings are below 50, while the 12-month habitat shows eight readings below 50. However, there is a sharp change in terms of slowing with 20 jurisdictions showing weaker 3-month averages than six-month averages whereas only five show weaker six-month averages than 12-month averages and only 8 show weaker 12-month averages than they had for the 12-month period of 12 months ago.

The Hi/Low percentile standings for individual countries show the percentile standings of the current months reading between the highest and lowest readings of the last 4½ years. In contrast, the queue percentile standings evaluate the current diffusion reading as a ranked position among all other readings, as in the top 90% of all readings or in the bottom 9% of all readings without regard to the actual magnitude of the reading; the reading is ordinal in percentage terms. The readings for the hi/low vs. the queue standings are quite different because the hi/low data are based on only three numbers while the queue standings are based on all observations in the period over which they are ranked. On data back to January 2019, the average and median low readings are in the 25 to 27 range for diffusion readings. The high readings are only at a level of 59 for the average and for the median. Because the low readings are so much lower (25 points from the lowest reading possible while high readings are some 40 points below the higher reading possible) the high low percentiles generate higher readings.

The queue percentile readings are quite weak, averaging a 42-percentile standing with nearly the same result as its median.

The composite PMIs blend the weighted readings for manufacturing and services in each responding unit. Weakness continues to be the order of the day, but it is still only creeping weakness since both the average and the median readings overall this month are above 50, indicating that expansion is still the most common result. A series of large countries and regions EMU, Germany, France, Spain, and the U.K. are below 50 on their composite readings; however, the U.S., Japan and China are still above 50 in August. But among all those large countries, only Japan improved month-to-month in August. Downward pressure remains in force broadly and among the large economies.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Global| Sep 01 2023
Manufacturing PMIs Show Mixed Results in August
The global manufacturing sector showed uneven results in August with some of the larger economies showing some improvement, such as the euro area, Germany, France, and Japan. However, the U.K. and the U.S., both relatively large economies, show backtracking.

Among these 18 early reporting economic units, 10 of them show improvement in August. Looking at the changes in the manufacturing diffusion indexes between three-months and six-months shows improvement in six countries. Looking at the changes between six-months and 12-months, 10 countries show improvement. Looking at the changes between now in 12 months ago, there are only four that show improvements. Those four are Mexico, China, Russia, and India, but the data from Russia at this point are quite suspect since it is on a war-time footing. China, on the other hand, had been a long period of struggling as it has an entangled exist from Covid problems; it began to make some recovery. However, now it still struggles with various problems. China may not be an example of an economy on the upswing despite what the PMI trends are telling us. China does show deterioration over three months as does Russia.

We look at the median reading. The median for August is 48.8; this is slightly reduced from July's 49.2. However, August is still above June's level of 47.8. There's no discerning a trend from this choppiness. It's just clear that the manufacturing PMIs have been chopping around in an area below 50 showing some slight deterioration in the manufacturing sector, but there doesn't seem to be any trending in place. If we look at three-months compared to six-months compared to 12-months, we find the three-month average is at 48.5, just a tick higher than the six-month average at 48.4 which is the same as the average of 48.4 for 12-months. Once again, we get this sense the global economy has been frozen in this slight contraction phase that hasn't gotten better and hasn't gotten worse but with central banks fighting inflation and with this disruptive war going on between Ukraine and Russia. Given other geopolitical tensions, it's made the economic situation seem even more tenuous.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Europe| Aug 31 2023
Unemployment in EMU Stays Put in July
Unemployment rates in the European Monetary Union are stationary at 6.4% in July after falling in June to 6.4% from 6.5% in May.

Country level results: Among the twelve European Monetary Union members who report unemployment rates early, individual country unemployment rates fell in Belgium, Spain, Ireland, and Greece in July. Unemployment rates rose in Austria, Finland, France, Italy, and in the Netherlands. Broadly speaking, unemployment rates in the monetary union are trending lower. However, the data for July offer a cautionary tale regarding where trends are headed. At the bottom of the table, we provide reference unemployment rates for the United States, the up-to-date claimant rate of unemployment in the United Kingdom, and the unemployment rate for Japan. The U.K. and Japan both saw elevated unemployment rates in July compared to June. The U.S. rate continued to snake down after having seen a relatively sharp increase in the unemployment rate in May that has since unwound.

Sequential trends Sequential trends for unemployment rates show that for the overall European Monetary Union rate the unemployment rate is down by 0.3 percentage points over 12 months; it's also down by 0.3 percentage points over six months; it is lower by 0.1 percentage points over three months. Trends across countries show declines in the unemployment rate over 12 months, six months and three months for Italy, Ireland, Greece, and Spain. Portugal shows an increase over 12 months, with declines over six months and three months. Other countries show increases on all horizons; those are Austria, Finland, France, and Luxembourg. The Netherlands shows an increase over 12 months and three months, with no change over six months.

Ranking countries by their level of unemployment We can also look at the broad rankings for the unemployment rate. Here we find that all the monetary union countries except Luxembourg and Austria have an unemployment rate that ranks in the lower 50% of its distribution of unemployment rates (on data since 1994) marking them all as below their historic medians on this timeline. Belgium, Germany, France, and Ireland all have unemployment rates that are in the lower 10 percentile of their respective historic queues of unemployment rate observations. These are countries with exceptionally low unemployment rates compared to their own historic standards. Make no mistake: European labor markets are tight! Among the countries with unemployment rates below they're medians but somewhat higher, we have Greece with the 40.7 percentile standing, Spain with a 25.9 percentile standing and Finland with the 22.4 percentile standing. All of these are moderately low to still exceptionally low unemployment rates indicating strong labor market conditions across the monetary union- just about everywhere.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Europe| Aug 30 2023
EU Indexes Continue Their Descent
The EU sentiment indexes for the EMU in August fell to 93.3 from 94.5 in July, continuing a steady decline as depicted in the chart. Industrial reading eroded, consumer confidence eroded, construction eroded and services eroded; only the retail reading at -5 was unchanged on a month-to-month basis. The percentile standing with the overall index is at its 24.2 percentile, putting it in the lower quartile of its queue of values. The industrial EMU readings are in the bottom 26-percentile, consumer confidence is in its bottom 19th percentile and services are in the lower 34th percentile of their historic queue. And the two readings stand above their respective medians, retailing at its 62nd percentile reading and construction at its 72nd percentile reading.

Across countries Percentile standings across the monetary union are weak with only three countries Greece, Malta, and Cyprus - all of them small economies- sporting EU index values above their respective historic medians (above a 50-percentiel standing). In August, there are declines in eight of the reporting 18 monetary union members. However, the three largest economies in the monetary union, Germany France, and Italy, each experienced sharp declines in August. Germany posted a decline of 2.6% on the month, France, a decline of 2.7%, and Italy dropped 1.1%. The fourth largest economy in the monetary union, Spain, posted its second monthly increase in a row, rising by 1.5% in August. But among the countries that saw declines, most of them were quite severe declines as we can see in the table below. Portugal saw a drop of 3.4% month-to-month, Austria logged a drop of 4.6%, Malta fell by 4.8%, and Belgium fell by 1.2%. Among all the negative month-to-month values, only Lithuania had a modest decline of 0.2%.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Germany| Aug 29 2023
German Confidence Stuck in a Low Rut Since May; Economic Sentiment Is the Worst Since December 2022
The GfK survey of the consumer climate in Germany’s economy weakened in September and has held to a narrow range of values since May 2023. German climate hit its lows in the cycle between May 2022 to April 2023 reaching negative values and the GfK headline was as low as -42.8, logging three straight months with a -40 (or greater) negative value for the headline. However, that super-weak stretch came between October and December of 2022. Then, from January 2023 through April, the numbers repaired to reside in the range around a -30 reading. But since May 2023, readings of around -25 have held sway and have been relatively steady in this survey.

Climate components Economic expectations, like other components in the GfK survey, lagged by a month; its most recent value is for August 2023 at -6.2; it's the weakest reading since December 2022. Income expectations also slipped in August, falling to -11.5 in August from -5.1 in July. Income expectations were last weaker in March 2023. The assessment of the propensity to buy has also slipped, falling to -17 in August from -14.3 in July; it was last weaker in February 2023. Clearly, the German economy has slipped into another weak patch at a time it is already quite weak.

Graphic tale of German consumer climate erosion The graph of the GfK climate measure shows that prior to the onset of COVID, the German economy had been pumping out very steady positive readings for confidence. And then with the development of Covid, confidence/climate fell sharply, recovered, waffled, and struggled back to weigh in logging several small positive readings before the end of 2021. After that, it’s more serious nosedive. We can see that economic expectations had fallen ahead of the arrival of Covid, and we're not worsened dramatically by Covid itself; economic expectations improved after Covid struck and we're rebounding to substantially higher readings than they had seen- even in the five years before Covid struck. With the invasion of Ukraine by Russia, the economic survey for Germany collapsed and it has been waffling, low, with weak monthly responses ever since.

Weak percentile standings The queue percentile standing for the climate gauge is in the lower 5% of its historic queue of values. Economic expectations reside in their lower 26-percentile, income expectations are in their lower 15-percentile and the propensity to buy is at its lower 19th percentile. All of these are unambiguously low readings, in or very near the lower quartile of their respective distributions of observations. Some stand quite low within that lower quartile. The overall climate gauge has the lowest standing of all. It also is the freshest observation and the only one for the month of September.

Other Europe The table also includes assessments for Italy, France, and the United Kingdom; these are less up-to-date than the GfK reading for Germany. For Italy, the most recent observation is for July. For France and the U.K., the most recent observations are for August. Italian consumer confidence has a 74-percentile standing and it slipped in July to 106.7 from 108.6 in June. In France, the August reading for conference slipped to 84.9 from July’s 85.3 as confidence logged a 14-percentile standing. U.K. confidence improved to a -25 reading in August from a -30 reading in July; there, confidence has a 26.7 percentile standing, another weak reading. European economies are struggling, and this is reflected in uneven consumer confidence assessments. Manufacturing is under pressure. There is still high inflation, as central banks are raising interest rates. Concerns over the still roaring war between Ukraine and Russia are still rife. These conditions have not changed in a number of months and the consumer confidence readings continue to be impaired by these conditions.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Global| Aug 28 2023
Money and Credit Trends in EMU and Globally Remain Weak But Stir
In July, global money supplies and credit demands continued to be weak or to decline- for the most part. However, on the oil front, prices rebounded strongly after a step back in June. The impulse to prices coming from money supplies is very weak despite this reversal.

Euro area trends In the euro area, money supply (M2) is falling 1.5% at an annual rate in July and credit measures are growing at less than 1/2 percent at an annual rate. Over three months money and credit growth in the European Monetary Union are declining. Over six months money and credit measures are declining, and over 12 months money is declining with credit measures up by barely 1% year-on-year. However, sequentially, the progress of growth rates to continually lower level has been truncated over three months compared to six months but not by much since we're still seeing declining growth rates, they're just smaller declines than over six months.

Turning to real balances in the monetary union, the growth of money and credit is negative over three months, six months, twelve months, two years, and three years - on all those horizons for all three measures. The decline in the demand for inflation-adjusted credit rolls on and real money balances continue to contract. For the most part, the peak negative growth rates are over twelve months with M2 money supply in the monetary union falling at a 6.2% annual rate, logging a -6.1% annual rate decline over six months and then a 4.9% annual rate drop over three months. That's a slight diminishing of downward pressure but the emphasis is on slight. Credit to residents falls by 4.3% over twelve months, slips at a 3.9% annual rate over six months and falls at a 2.9% annual rate over three months. Similarly, private credit falls at a 4.1% annual rate over twelve months, falls at a 3.8% annual rate over six months, and falls at a 2.9% annual rate over three months; these are all substantial negative growth rates, but there's evidence across all three measures of slightly diminishing downward pressures.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief