Introducing

Robert Brusca

Robert A. Brusca is Chief Economist of Fact and Opinion Economics, a consulting firm he founded in Manhattan. He has been an economist on Wall Street for over 25 years. He has visited central banking and large institutional clients in over 30 countries in his career as an economist. Mr. Brusca was a Divisional Research Chief at the Federal Reserve Bank of NY (Chief of the International Financial markets Division), a Fed Watcher at Irving Trust and Chief Economist at Nikko Securities International. He is widely quoted and appears in various media. Mr. Brusca holds an MA and Ph.D. in economics from Michigan State University and a BA in Economics from the University of Michigan. His research pursues his strong interests in non aligned policy economics as well as international economics. FAO Economics’ research targets investors to assist them in making better investment decisions in stocks, bonds and in a variety of international assets. The company does not manage money and has no conflicts in giving economic advice.

Publications by Robert Brusca

Japan| Sep 29 2023
Japan’s Industrial Production Is Mixed in August
Industrial production in Japan in August rose by 0.2% after falling by 1.6% in July. Manufacturing output in August fell by 0.2% after falling by 2.4% in July. Overall industrial production has made a gain while manufacturing production is pulling back slightly.

Sequential growth rates from 12-months to six-months to three-months show lessening weakness culminating in a small positive growth rate over three months for total industry output. Overall industrial production falls at a 3.4% annual rate over 12 months, falls at a 1.1% annual rate over six months, and then makes a 6% annual rate positive gain over three months. Manufacturing follows suit. Its sequential rebound shows output falling by 3.8% over 12 months, falling at a 2.7% annual rate over six months, then advancing at an 8.5% annual rate over three months. While the monthly data are somewhat chaotic, both overall and manufacturing industrial production are showing accelerating sequential growth.

The sequential acceleration is borne out by the chart at the top of this report; however, it's part of a still very flat growth process where we can see that three-month, six-month, and 12-month growth rates for industrial output have been in a narrow range and have been somewhat arbitrarily changing places for a relatively long period of time. The chart traces data back to September 2022 and on this timeline no clear pattern of acceleration over any sustained period can be identified.

The paradox here is that quarter-to-date all industry and sector as well as aggregate measures are showing a decline in output, two months into the third quarter. The sequential growth rates, on the other hand, give us some sense of an acceleration in progress. These two measures conflict with one another.

The manufacturing industries, textiles, and transportation, show sequential growth rates that are getting progressively weaker from 12-months to six-months to three-months. These are contrary to the trends for manufacturing overall.

By sector, consumer goods output is up by 1.3% over 12 months and gains at a 2% rate over six-months but then drops at a 13.2% annual rate over three months – it is decelerating. Intermediate goods show the progressive acceleration that we see in the headline as output falls by 2.6% over 12 months, falls by 0.4% at an annual rate over six months, and then advances by 4.4% at an annual rate over three months. Investment goods show an unclear sequential pattern falling by 11.1% over 12 months, reducing that drop to -4.7% annualized over six months, but then having an accelerated drop at a -20.1% rate over three months.

Mining shows a pattern that looks close to progressive weakness, with an 8.6% decline over 12 months, a similar 7.6% decline over six months, followed by an accelerated 17.3% annual rate fall over three months.

Not surprisingly electric & gas utilities output shows persistent strength with output rising 2.2% over 12 months, advancing at a 9.5% pace over six months, and rising at a a 24.9% pace over three months. Utilities output simply feeds current activity and demand and there is less ability to stockpile output from the sector.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Europe| Sep 28 2023
EC Commission Indexes for EMU Slide Lower Again
The European Commission indexes of overall confidence and sector assessments for September slipped lower and the European Monetary Union (EMU) with the overall gauge dropping to 93.3 from 93.6 in August. At that level, the overall index has a ranking among historical observations back to 1990 in its lower 24th percentile, an extremely weak reading.

Component or sector readings for EMU The component readings for the index show slippage or unchanged values for all components except the industrial sector where there was a month-to-month improvement in September to -9 from a -10 reading in August. The service sector assessment was unchanged in September at a level of 4.0. The retail and construction indexes each slipped to a reading of -6 in September from a reading of -5 in August. Consumer confidence in the EMU fell to -17.8 in September from -16 in August; it has the lowest component ranking among the five components at a 14.1 percentile standing in September. Confidence in the EMU is doing very badly. The industrial and services assessments also have standings below their 50th percentiles. Retailing and construction have percentile standings above their historic medians (which means they're above the 50th percentile). Construction has a relatively firm standing at a 70th percentile standing; retailing has a 58.7 percentile queue standing.

Country level performance in September 18 of 19 members report country level confidence readings for September; 8 of 19 members show month-to-month declines, the same number as in August and one more than July. Among the largest countries (Germany, France, Italy, and Spain), Italy and Spain showed declines in September while Germany, France, and Italy showed declines in August. Germany and France showed declines in July as well. The large countries have consistently been showing weakness. Because the overall European monetary union gauge is weighted for economic size, this weakness among the largest economies weighs on the overall index.

Standings show broad and intense weakness The monetary union gauge itself has a 24.2 queue percentile standing; this compares to a 15.9 percentile standing in Germany, the largest economy in the EMU. France, the second largest economy, has a standing at its 37.5 percentile. Italy, the third largest economy, logs a 41.1 percentile standing. Spain, the fourth largest economy, has a 39.5 percentile standing. Among the remaining 14 countries, only three have queue percentile standings above their 50% mark. Those are Malta with a 99.6 percentile standing, Greece with the 71.5 percentile standing, and Cyprus with a 62.7 percentile standing. Most countries large or small have overall sentiment standings below their 50th percentile and generally substantially below their 50th percentiles. Among the largest four economies, the highest percentile standing is from Italy with a 41.1 percentile standing; among the other 14 in the table, setting aside the three that have readings above the 50% mark, the highest percentile standing is 39.2% in Lithuania, followed by 33.6% in Slovakia, 29% in Latvia, and 28.5% in Luxembourg.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Global| Sep 27 2023
EMU Money and Credit Decline Broadly in August; Globally Money Growth Remains Weak and Largely Contracts
Monthly money and credit developments in July hinted at a possible reversal in the ongoing global declines in money and credit trends one month ago. However, in August the data for money and credit in the European Monetary Union (EMU), as well as money supply data from the U.S. and the U.K., show that the declines in money on the month are back in force. Only Japan shows an increase in money supply in August and that's not surprising since Japan has a legacy of positive money growth rates unlike other major monetary centers in this table.

EMU conditions Nominal growth- The European Monetary Union shows negative money supply growth in both July and August as well as over 12 months, six months, and three months. Money supply trends are flat with growth declining mostly at about a 2% pace or a little more over the three-, six-, and 12-month intervals. Credit growth in the EMU remains weak and registers tiny growth rates over 12 months compared to negative growth rates of about -1% over both three- and six-month horizons for overall credit and private credit.

Real growth- Inflation-adjusted growth rates for credit and money in the EMU show a table full of negative numbers. The steepest negative growth rate is over 12 months at minus 7% for M2, that gives way to -5.7% over six months and then steps back up to minus 6.8% over three months. So, we're not able to say that the decline in real balances is tapering off in the monetary union. Credit to residents has its steepest sequential growth rate over three months at -5.9%, compared to -4.9% over 12 months. Private credit posts nearly identical growth numbers to total credit as well as nearly identical trends. Money and credit in the EMU, looked at sequentially, looked at in nominal terms or looked at in real terms, show significant ongoing weakness and possibly stepped-up weakening.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Europe| Sep 26 2023
Early Read on EMU PPI Suggests Growing Pressure
Price trends in the early reporting European Monetary Union countries show a mixed bag of results for the PPI. In August, we have six countries listed in the table of which five are monetary union members. Only two show PPI declines in August. Germany shows a decline of 0.1% and Denmark, a member of the economic union, not of the monetary union, shows a decline of 1.1%. In August, the consumer price index core HICP gains 0.3%, building on a 0.5% gain from July. The early inflation data from the monetary union suggest that the pace of the inflation decline is shifting and slowing.

Tail wind becomes head wind- Some of this pressure undoubtedly stems from Brent oil prices that rose by 6.1% in August and by 6.3% in July, both are month-to-month gains. Brent oil prices are up at a 56.8% annual rate over three months and a 3.5% annual rate over six months, compared to dropping by 12.7% year-over-year. Energy prices are no longer a tailwind for falling inflation in the monetary union.

Hints on core inflation- While the consumer price core measure shows increases in each of the last two months, for Germany at least, the ex-energy PPI gauge shows a 0.3% decline in August and a 0.4% decline in July. The German PPI excluding energy is showing a faster deceleration as it rises 1.4% year-over-year, falls at a 2.3% annual rate over six months and then falls at a 3.3% annual rate over three months.

Oil impacts the PPI and CPI- Inflation trends are somewhat confused and complicated, which is not surprising after having seen such a burst of inflation and then an unwinding of oil prices. Now, as oil prices begin to firm and rise, we're going to see an upside to headline inflation; it's unclear exactly how core inflation is going to navigate in this environment. We would expect core producer price inflation to be somewhat more sensitive to price pressures from oil and consumer prices to be less sensitive to energy pressures. But when we look at some, admittedly limited, core readings, what we're seeing in August for Germany are core prices ex energy continuing to fall while the HICP for the EMU, excluding tobacco food & energy, is rising, and slightly accelerating over three months compared to six-months.

Inflation trends- Central banks tend to focus on year-over-year inflation rates and for the monetary union we're looking at PPI prices that are declining sharply over this group of countries although for Germany the core ex-energy is up by 1.4% and, of course, the ECB is looking at consumer prices union-wide. There we see the core is up at a 5.3% annual rate, decelerating only to a 4.8% annual rate over six months and then ticking back up to a 4.9% annual rate over three months. Oil prices are wreaking havoc with these trends. Producer prices generate massive declines in inflation over 12 months and over six months; then, there are scattered results over three months as oil prices begin to turn and as the lags apparently work through different countries at different speeds. Over three months PPI prices are falling at a double-digit rate (or at least nearly so) in Germany, Denmark, and Ireland. Over three months producer prices are rising at a 3.3% annual rate in Finland, at a 6.3% annual rate in Spain, and at a 7.7% annual rate in Portugal.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Germany| Sep 25 2023
German IFO Remains Extremely Weak
IFO survey remains quite weak: The IFO survey of the German economy in September continues to generate extremely weak readings. The all-sector climate reading in September edges slightly stronger to -20.2 from -20.4 in August. At that level, the all-sector climate index ranks in the bottom 7.8% of all observations on data back to December 1991. Ranking the al-sector metric from February 2022, when Russia invaded Ukraine, the ranking is in the lower 5% of all readings since then. Climate is unambiguously weak. And it has essentially no momentum or negative momentum.

Climate readings are weak The climate readings in September for manufacturing, construction, wholesaling, retailing, and services are little-changed. There's a small improvement in construction month-to-month, a small improvement in wholesaling, and a very small improvement in manufacturing. The other metrics worsened slightly. The strongest queue standing among any of the sectors for climate in September is for construction at a 29.6 percentile standing, followed by retailing at a 25.4 percentile standing; the weakest reading is for manufacturing at a 5.6 percentile standing and services at a 6.3 percentile standing.

Current readings are weak Current conditions in September generate a positive reading of 2.0, but that slips from 2.7 in August. The September reading has a 13.8 percentile standing on data from December 1991 and it is the weakest reading since Ukraine was invaded by Russia in February 2022. Current conditions in September improved slightly in manufacturing, while deteriorating, and all other sectors. The services sector posts a net positive reading at +9.2 in September, but that's weaker than the +12.2 reading in August. Queue standings for the sectors show the strongest reading is for construction at the 54th percentile and at retailing at about its 54th percentile as well; the weakest current reading is from services with a 14.7 percentile standing, with manufacturing and wholesaling having standings in their 30th percentiles, respectively. Of the five sectors, three of them have the weakest readings since Ukraine was invaded by Russia; manufacturing is an exception with a bottom 5 percentile standing and retailing with a bottom 10 percentile standing. Despite being ‘exceptions’ these all are very weak readings.

Expectations have abysmally weak rankings Expectations show rankings that show weaker rankings than their current rankings for every sector up and down the line with the all-sector ranking at the 6.2 percentile mark; and no sector has a reading higher than a 7.1 percentile standing. However, month-to-month there are some hints of improvement with the all-sector index improving to -26.2 in September from -26.6 in August. Wholesaling, retailing, and services all make small improvements month-to-month as manufacturing and construction show essentially unchanged or weaker readings month-to-month. One difference in the expectations column is that the ranked standings since the invasion occurred are stronger than for the current readings, although this doesn't amount to much because the global rankings are still even weaker. But compared to values over the period since the invasion occurred, the ranking for wholesaling in September has a 50th percentile standing and retailing has a 65th percentile standing. The all-sector index has a 30-percentile standing with the weakest reading from manufacturing at a 15-percentile standing. Nonetheless, it's hard to characterize any of this as good news. It’s just not vying for a ranking as the worst news.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Europe| Sep 22 2023
EMU PMIs ‘Stabilize’ at Weak Levels
The S&P flash PMIs for the composite manufacturing and services sectors for the September readings show a stronger Germany, leading to a stronger reading in the European Monetary Union in the composite. Meanwhile, France, the United Kingdom, Japan, and the United States, all report weaker composite readings for September.

Composites are broadly weaker- Germany’s strengthening is in the composite as well as for manufacturing and services separately. This helps to push the services sector in the EMU to a stronger reading although the EMU manufacturing reading is weaker month-to-month. France shows weaker readings in the composite as well as for both manufacturing and services. Japan follows suit on that score. The U.S. and the U.K. each report a weaker composite driven by a weaker service sector that dominates a somewhat stronger manufacturing sector in both the U.S and in the U.K.

Only two composites show net expansion underway- Only the U.S. and Japan have composite PMI readings above 50 in September, indicating expansion. And the only sector readings with PMI values above 50 are for services in the U.S. and in Japan, as well.

Sequential trends- The sequential readings from 12-months to 6-months to 3-months show weakening for the composite and for both sectors in the EMU, in Germany, in France, in the United Kingdom, and in Japan. The exception is the U.S. that is stronger on balance over 3 months for the composite and for the services sector. Comparing the 6-month PMI averages to the 12-month averages, conditions are broadly stronger across sectors and the composites. The exception is France that weakens on all three metrics. The U.S. and Japan strengthen on all three metrics, while the U.K. Germany, and the EMU strengthen on their services measures which dominate the composite, making it stronger over 6 months compared to 12 months. Comparing the 12-month readings to 12-months ago, everything is weaker except for services and the composite in Japan.

Evaluation of PMI levels- The queue percentile standings rarely change much month-to-month and across these metrics we continue to see queue standings well below their neutral, 50% mark, generally below the 20% mark for most countries, across most sectors, with the sole exception being Japan that has the service sector reading at its 81st percentile; that helps the composite to a 75.5 percentile standing. However, despite month-to-month changes and broader trends in the sequential numbers, it's clear that the PMI values being posted are extremely weak.

Net 3-month changes- The final column of the table shows the net changes over 3 months; over three months these are overpoweringly weak. They're negative numbers for all the countries and all the sectors with the sole exception of manufacturing in the United States. The last 3 months have been weak.

On balance: The bottom line for the S&P flash numbers for September is that weak conditions continue to prevail and to dominate. There is some rebound in Germany that helps the European Monetary Union to post an uneven rebound, but the levels of activity indicated by the composite, the manufacturing sector and the services sector continue to be extremely weak.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
France| Sep 21 2023
French INSEE Survey: Mixed Picture; Manufacturing Improves While Services Remain Dead Flat
Manufacturing and Services The INSEE surveys for France in September rose for manufacturing while it remained dead flat for services. The manufacturing survey rebounded to 98.6 in September but was still below its July value of 100.7. The manufacturing rebound in September is limited; activity remains weak, historically at a percentile standing of 31.3% in the bottom third of historic observations.

Manufacturing Climate and production- Manufacturing production expectations in September remained negative but improved to -6.2 from -9.0 in August. The recent production trend worsened, falling to -6.3 from -4.0 in August. However, respondents referring to their own industry reflected a ‘personal likely trend’ that's much stronger at 14.1 compared to 2.5 in August. Survey respondents are downbeat on manufacturing overall, but upbeat on their individual sectors. That's a divergence worth watching. And it's also a rather significant divergence because the standing for the recent industry trend is at its lower 15th percentile whereas the standing for the ‘personal likely trend’ is at its 77.7 percentile. There's an extreme chasm between what respondents think is going to happen to industry overall compared to their optimism on their own individual surveys. Is it optimism or denial? Those two readings on ‘likely trends’ compare to an overall manufacturing production expectation that has a 39.7 percentile standing. That standing is below its 50th percentile, below its median, and weak.

Orders and demand- Orders and demand are little-changed month-to-month in manufacturing. The September value is -21.4 compared to -21.2 in August. For foreign orders & demand, there is slight improvement to a reading of -13.9 in September from -15.1 in August. The percentile standing for overall orders & demand is a 32.8 percentile standing and that compares to a 44th percentile standing for foreign orders & demand; both are below median values, and both are weak.

Inventories- The response for inventory levels declined slightly in September to 14.8 from 17.8 in August, but these are strong values with 87-percentile standing for the September value.

Prices- Prices show increased pressure month-to-month with the ‘own likely price trend’ moving up to 5.2 in September from 2.2 in August compared to the manufacturing overall price trend that moves up to 8.9 from 5.0 in August. The ‘own likely price trend’ in September is still below its July value, whereas the manufacturing price level in September is assessed at twice its July level. The standing for the ‘own likely price trend’ is a 55.9 percentile standing, compared to a below-median 46.2 percentile standing for the manufacturing price level. While the assessment of manufacturing prices is below the assessment for the ‘own unlikely price trend’ the two standings aren't all that far apart.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
United Kingdom| Sep 20 2023
Inflation in the UK: A Familiar Picture; Little Decline in Y/Y Core Inflation but a Sharp Drop over 3 Months
The U.K. inflation reported in August paints a familiar picture of the trend for inflation. The CPIH measure rose by 0.4% after falling by 0.1% in July. The core measure excluding food, energy, alcohol, and tobacco was flat in August after rising 0.5% in July. Among the ten major headlines reported for U.K. inflation, the price level change accelerated in only four of them in August compared to July.

Sequential inflation Sequential inflation in the U.K. as measured by the headline rose by 6.3% over 12 months, decelerated to a 4.6% annual rate over 6 months, and decelerated further to a 2% annual rate over 3 months. For the core rate, inflation rose 5.9% over 12 months, accelerated to a 6.2% annual rate over 6 months, and then fell sharply to a 3.2% annual rate over 3 months.

The odd tale of core inflation The tracking of the core inflation rate by 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month calculations is presented in the chart at the top of this report, and it's clear that the 3-month inflation rate, even for the core, has broken sharply lower. For the 6-month rate, there is a more complicated bump-up in inflation before it begins to decline, leaving the 6-month increase slightly higher than its pace over 12 months. The 3-month inflation rate traces out a strange path in which it seems to peak in early-2022 as it proceeds to soften its pace through the end of the year, before spiking to a sharply higher peak rate and then diving sharply and essentially returning the inflation rate for the core back to what had appeared to be the downtrend for the earlier pace of decline before the secondary spike arrived. All of this makes evaluating what's going on in the core much more difficult since the 3-month inflation rate is so different than either the 6-month pace or 12-month pace. Also, because the core has exhibited this extremely rogue behavior, imbuing it with the kind of volatility we normally expect to see in the headline rather than in the core, trusting it becomes more a matter of faith.

The Bank of England The Bank of England must be breathing a sigh of relief, in the wake of these developments. Not only has inflation turned lower but it's done it without having a substantial lift in the unemployment rate. The claimant rate of unemployment, that is more up-to-date, shows that unemployment has moved up to 4% in August from 3.9% in June, not much of an elevation particularly given the deceleration that has occurred in the inflation rate. The headline inflation rate has turned very sharply lower, and the core rate has turned low. The sequential rates of growth, however, are not the whole story. The core rate hasn't moved as much if we simply look at the performance of the year-over-year pace. But the performance in the core over 3 months and 6 months suggests that there's going to be more deceleration in the 12-month pace in the months ahead.

Inflation diffusion The diffusion data that look at the inflation acceleration in one period compared to the previous period show that a year ago the 12-month pace was accelerating in all categories compared to 12-months earlier. Currently the 12-month pace compared to a year ago is accelerating modestly with the diffusion calculation of 54.5; for diffusion the neutral reading is 50%. At that reading, the proportion of categories with inflation accelerating and decelerating is balanced. Over six months, diffusion declines to a 45.5% level; over 3 months, it falls extremely sharply to a 9.1% level. Over 3 months, inflation accelerates only in one category. And that's comparing the 3-month rate to the 6-month rate that already has declined; the acceleration for inflation over 3 months is only from the category ‘education’ where the annualized rate for inflation ‘picks up’ to 3.7% from 3.6%. These are quite impressive trends for the U.K. if the trends have staying power.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Europe| Sep 19 2023
EMU HICP and Core: Turning the Corner on Excess Inflation s-l-o-w-l-y
Inflation in the European monetary area continue to be strong with August rising by 0.6% month-to-month after rising 0.4% in July and 0.2% in June. The closely watched core measure turned weaker in August rising by 0.3% after a 0.5% gain in both June and July.

Monthly inflation basics Among the four largest euro area members, all but Spain showed inflation increases month-to-month. Posting a 1.4% increase in its July HICP, August brought a much lower 0.7% increase. And what was a significant month-to-month deceleration for Spain was also the second largest monthly headline gain among the Big Four economies. Core inflation for the four largest economies accelerated in only two of the four largest economies. Germany showed inflation excluding energy rising to 0.4% in August after a 0.2% gain in July; Italy's core crept up by 0.1% after being flat in July. The core inflation rate in France edged up 0.1% month-to-month after a 0.5% gain in July, while Spain’s core rose by 0.4% in August after rising a sharp 1.1% in July. Spain’s 0.4% core gain was a deceleration and also tied for the strongest month-to-month core gain across the Big Four economies in August. Comparisons always are complicated when you look for context.

Trends in general When cast in terms of annualized inflation trends – 12-months to 6-months to 3-months- the trends were substantially mixed with negative results over three months. Inflation decelerations were broadly posted over 6 months compared to 12-months and for 12-month inflation rates compared to their values of 12-months ago. Headline inflation over 12 months broadly decelerates compared to 12-months ago while core inflation broadly accelerates.

Headline vs. core trends-acceleration/deceleration Headline inflation in August rises 5.3% over 12 months. That decelerates to a 3.3% pace over six months then ramps up to a 5.2% pace over three months. The 3-month pace is sharply higher than the 6-month pace; and the 3-month pace is only a tick weaker than the year-over-year gain. Core inflation in the EMU is up by 5.4% over 12 months then decelerates to a 4.8% pace over 6 months. Over 3 month inflation comes back to life with the EMU core rising by 5% annualized, on balance a speed-up over 6 months and a moderate slowing by less than one-half of one percentage point comparing the 3-month pace to the 12-month pace.

Sequential trends Looking at these same trends for headline inflation sequentially, all headlines show slower gains over 12-months compared to 12-months ago and another slowdown follows over 6 months compared to 12-months. But over 3 months headline inflation accelerates in all Big Four economies with two of them showing faster inflation over 3 months than over 12 months annualized. Inflation over 3 months accelerates compared to 12-months in Germany and Spain while it decelerates in France (by one-half of one percentage point) and in Italy where the inflation rate is nearly halved over 3 months compared to 12-months.

Core inflation sequentially Core inflation is more interesting from a trend standpoint. It shows year-on-year accelerations in three of four of the largest EMU economies compared to its 12-month pace of 12-months ago. Only Spain shows less pressure over 12 months. Over six months core inflation pressures drop broadly across each of the Big Four economies and by significant amounts. But over 3 months inflation accelerates in two countries and decelerates in the other two. Inflation surges to a 7.9% annual rate in Spain over three months, topping both its 6-month and 12-month pace. In Germany, ex-energy inflation picks up from 3.6% over six months to 3.9% over three months and still shows a two-percentage point back down from its year-on-year pace.

Oil continues to be a disinflation factor The bottom of the table chronicles the performance of oil prices showing Brent is still favorable monthly falling in both July and August -as well as declining on balance over 12 months, 6 months and 3 months.

Inflation evaluation-strange brew The table shows still unacceptable inflation levels and less than reassuring trends across the largest EMU economies as well as for the weighted-average impact of all member countries on EMU itself. With an inflation objective of about 2%, the ECB finds the five-year headline gain (compounded pace) at 3.6% compared to 2.6% for the core rate. Headline inflation over five years for the Big Four range from a high of 4% in Germany to a low of 3.1% in Spain – had I tried to tell you ten-year years ago that would happen, you never would have believed me! And this is for inflation over five years – not a monthly quirk. Core inflation over five years averages the highest among the four largest EMU economies in Germany at 3.2% and the lowest in Italy at 2.3%.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Canada| Sep 18 2023
Canadian Housing Starts Weaken; Broad Saw-tooth Declining Pattern for Still-resilient Starts
Canadian housing starts have been in a pattern of saw-tooth declines from their 2021 peak. However, starts, viewed broadly, in a longer-term framework, are still quite firm. Starts are higher than their August 2023 level in only twenty-three of the last thirty-seven months, on data back to August 2020. Yet, the August 2023 reading is higher than nearly all monthly results prior to August 2020 (only seven exceptions on data back to January 1990 - 367 observations before August 2020). As a result, I view weakness in housing as limited and recent.

In Canada, housing is not weak and is holding up well. This is despite a 5-year mortgage rate of 5.99% in July, up from rates at or below 3.3% from January 2021 through September 2021. On data from January 2021, Canadian 5-year mortgage rates average 4.12% Their current 5.99% level in July is significantly higher. But interest rates and inflation rates move together and inflation rates are now moderating.

Canada’s 5-year mortgage rate is at 5.99%; historically it has been even higher from May 2006 through December 2008, more or less consistently. From January 1990 through December 2003, it also was above 5.99%. The current mortgage rate is high relative most recent historic experiences but not so much in a broad historic context. Still, mortgage rates moved up above their average since January 2012 (4.12%) as of April 2022 and rates have been elevated ever since. The five-year mortgage rate is currently on its cycle high, but it is only higher by 11 basis points from its level of eight months ago. The momentum for rising rates has dissipated.

The period of interest rate shock would seem to be over for the housing market. Canadian house prices have fallen year-over-year for only four-months in a row (April 2023- July 2023). On data back to 2000, housing prices in Canada rose by double digits only from June 2006 to January 2007… until during the Covid period, when prices rose by double digits from April 2021 through May 2022. House prices in July 2023 in Canada are still stronger than April, May and July of 2023 and are lower only than a string of months from April 2022 to March 2023.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Japan| Sep 15 2023
Japan’s Tertiary Sector Recovers in a Trend-dominated Report
Japan's tertiary index (service sector index) recovered in July, rising to 101.8 from 100.9 in June after it had reached 101.6 in May. The July recovery brings the index of tertiary sector activity up above its May level and leaves it with a relatively high year-over-year ranking of its growth rate’s top 10 percentile standing on data since 2011. In contrast, industry stepped back to an index reading of 103.8 in July from 105.7 in June. The July value is still above its May value, but the sector’s growth ranking has it in its 20.5 percentile, approximately the lower one-fifth of its historic level by ranking. The industry index is 4.6% below its level in January 2020 before COVID struck; the tertiary index is higher by only 0.2% since COVID struck. These two sector indexes have been either weak or lethargic over this 3½ year period.

Economy watchers indexes deliver a more upbeat reading; these diffusion indexes in July are all above 50 indicating expansion for the overall index and for the individual sectors the Economy watches index assesses. In July, the headline improved and most components improved, except for eating & drinking places and the overall metric for the services sector slipped to 57.5 in July from 60.7 in June but this reading still registers sector expansion. The economy watchers indexes have a growth ranking, for the most part, in the 80th to 90th percentile, the exception being a weaker ranking for employment growth.

The Teikoku readings are also diffusion indexes; they indicate more weakness than the economy watchers survey. Manufacturing, retailing, wholesaling, and construction all have readings below the 50% mark indicating weakening growth. Services post a 51.7 diffusion reading, a reading that improves relative to June and indicates sector expansion. The growth ranking on the Teikoku indexes has manufacturing below its historic median for growth. Retailing and services have rankings above their respective 80th percentiles, marking them as relatively strong in terms of momentum.

It is not surprising to have these somewhat sensitive diffusion indexes giving us slightly different perspectives on what's going on in the various sectors. This month the good news from the METI sector indexes is for services improving and that's important because services are the employment generating sector; the employment growth ranking in the economy watchers framework is the relative weakest barometer among the various sector assessments in that survey.

The chart of the METI indexes for services and industry shows that not much has changed in the Japanese economy of late. The tertiary (services) index has continued to plug along somewhat sluggishly while the industry reading (mining and manufacturing) has been more volatile in a narrow range; it is currently riding a down cycle. But everything in the table for the month seems to be a reading in the normal flow of recent trends.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief
Europe| Sep 14 2023
Inflation in EMU Accelerates…Despite This Chart…
EMU inflation (month-to-month annualized) advanced at a 7.5% annual rate in August, up from a 5.7% pace in July. The year-on-year pace is at 4.2%. Countries showing the year-on-year pace of inflation faster than the overall EMU pace monthly are France, Germany, Italy, Portugal, and Ireland.

Inflation HAS broadly decelerated Inflation broadly decelerates over 12 months compared to its pace of 12-months ago. Every country in the table shows deceleration on this basis. The deceleration of inflation on this basis is -5.7 percentage points for the EMU overall; the median deceleration across members in the table is -6.1 percentage points. The greatest deceleration on this timeline is the -16.5 percentage-point drop off in the Netherlands, followed by a -11.1 percentage-point drop in Belgium, and a -10.5 percentage-point drop in Greece.

Compared to a year ago, the drop of in inflation is terrifically large. But that now seems to be a trend of the past that is withering.

The road ahead has more twists and turns Economists warn that the hard part of inflation reduction lies ahead. When oil prices fall, they can unwind inflation substantially, broadly, and quickly. But once inflation has been high for a while, other prices begin to trend with it and the higher inflation rate becomes entrenched. A dropping inflation rate is good news; however, at some point, the pace of inflation needs to be the focus rather than just the change in the pace. The focus on other prices that become sticky if inflation lingers too high for too long, is usually a spotlight on wages, since labor seeks to get back the compensation it loses when inflation rises. So, wage gains rise at a faster pace and then policy is pushing to reduce both wage and price inflation.

Inflation progress is slowing…down…does anyone care? Over six months, prices decelerate in the EMU by -0.9% at an annual rate compared to their 12-month pace. But deceleration only occurs for five of the twelve economies in the table (the EMU pace represents all EMU countries and is formed using weights reflecting the size of member economies). The median deceleration for 6-months compared to 12-months for reporting members in the table is not for a deceleration at all but for an acceleration of 2.7 percentage points.

Over 3 months, EMU inflation rises to 5.2% annualized from 3.3% over six months, an acceleration of 1.9 percentage points. Among table members, there is, nonetheless, an average deceleration of 0.3 percentage points (annualized). That would become 1.2 percentage points if the pace held for one year. Over 3 months, six of twelve members show deceleration.
by:Robert Brusca
|in:Economy in Brief