Economy in Brief

Inflation in the European Monetary Union turned flat in September with the headline flat and the core flat month-to-month. Over 12 months, headline inflation is rising at a 1.7% annual rate, the same as over six months; over three months, that pace steps down to 1.6%. Headline inflation is across the board consistent with the European central bank’s target of inflation of around 2%. Core inflation is higher. Over 12 months, the core runs hot at a 2.8% pace, rising over six months at a stronger 3.2% annual rate and then dipping to a 2.3% annual rate over three months. The three-month pace is coming much closer to the ECB's target for inflation.

The four largest economies in the EMU also had inflation fall in September. In Germany, prices dropped by 0.2%, the same as in Spain. Headline prices fell 0.7% in France and just ticked lower by 0.1% in Italy. Price dropping across the board is a special sign; in this case, it signals dropping oil prices.

Sequential inflation rates for headline inflation in large economies also are looking good. Germany and Spain have the highest 12-month inflation rates at 1.7%. France is next at 1.4% and then Italy logs a 0.7% 12-month inflation rate. However, over six months, inflation picks up above target for Italy and Germany to 2.7%; it cruises at a 1.9% annual rate in France and at 1% annual rate in Spain. Over three months, prices are flat in Germany, rising at a 0.2% annual rate in France, rising at a 0.3% annual rate in Spain, and rising at a 2.3% annual rate in Italy. The results we see for headline inflation clearly echoed across the large economies of the European Monetary Union.

However, as having been the case for some time, the sticking point for inflation is the core. This is because Brent oil prices fell by 8.1% in September and fell by 7.6% in August after rising by 0.1% in July. In fact, Brent oil prices are falling to a 47.7% annual rate over three months, falling at a 29.3% annual rate over six months, and falling at a 24% annual rate over 12 months. This helps to explain why headline inflation is doing so well. Core inflation is showing more signs of being stuck at a too-high level.

Core (ex-energy) inflation in the case of Germany is at a 2.6% annual rate over 12 months. Spain’s core pace is at a 2.4% annual rate, Italy logs a 1.9% annual rate, and France checks in at a 1.5% annual rate. For France and Italy, core inflation over 12 months is very much in the fold of the target pace, while in the case of Spain and Germany, the departures aren't so great as they both hover around 2.5% at an annual rate. However over six months, German inflation is still up by 2.4%, the same as in Italy. Spain logs in at a 2.2% annual rate. France stays with the low 1.5% annual rate. Over three months, inflation runs at a 2.8% annual rate for ex-energy in Germany; it's at a 2.4% annual rate for the core in Spain and 2.1% for the core in Italy, compared to an even weaker 0.4% annual rate in France.

Even with core inflation getting stuck in the EMU economy overall at 2.8%, inflation is still not very far from the ECB's goal and is broadly behaving for the large economies. And if economic data are deemed weak enough, inflation doesn't seem to be that far from the ECB's target nor is it misbehaving enough to keep ECB rate cuts off the table.

GDP growth in the European Monetary Union advanced by 1.5% in the third quarter at an annual rate, an acceleration from the second quarter’s 0.8% rise. It compares to gain of 1.2% at an annual rate in the first quarter. It is also the strongest quarterly rise since an increase of 2.4% at an annual rate in the third quarter of 2022. The year-over-year change is a gain of 0.9%, compared to 0.6% in the second quarter. That is the strongest year-over-year gain since the first quarter of 2023 when GDP rose by 1.4% year-over-year.

There are seven early reporting EMU members. Among these seven, four showed GDP advancing at a stronger pace in Q3 (Q/Q) than in Q2. Weaker growth was registered by Belgium and Italy with Portugal’s growth unchanged quarter-to-quarter.

Over the last six months, the large EMU economies have been holding back overall growth. The four largest EMU economies saw growth advance by 1.1% at an annual rate in 2024-Q3 compared to 2.5% growth in the rest of the EMU. In the second quarter, growth among the largest four economies also trailed growth in the rest of the monetary union. This is a switch from the usual standard. But year-on-year growth in the smaller economies is also higher in Q3 than in the largest four economies although that is the reverse of the previous three quarters.

Growth in the region has been weak for some time. The ranking of year-over-year growth rates on data back to 1997 shows all early reporting EMU members have rankings of growth in Q3 (year-on-year growth) below their historic medians (below a ranking of 50%) except Portugal and Spain. Portugal and Spain are exceptions with year-on-year growth rates that rank above 50% as well as above the ranking of the United States.

In the third quarter, only Italy has a negative quarter-to-quarter growth rate. Over four-quarters, only Germany and Ireland have negative quarter-to-quarter growth rates. Germany that does not have two quarters of negative (quarterly) growth back-to-back in the last three quarters has five consecutive quarters of negative year-over-year growth! However, the growth decline on this timeline has been modest. For Germany, this has been much more a period of pronounced economic stagnation than of economic decline.

Since 2011, the U.S. has had averages GDP growth about one percentage point (annualized) faster than the EMU. Since 2021, that difference has been the same on year-over-year comparisons, but it has become larger favoring the U.S. on quarterly comparisons. The median growth rate among early EMU reporters ranks at 40.2% while EMU growth ranks lower at 32.6% largely because the slower growing large economies have a greater weight in the EMU GDP construction than in the calculation of the median.