AsiaThis week, we explore potential opportunities in Asia if the US ultimately follows through with imposing tariffs on Canadian crude oil exports.
We begin by acknowledging the US-Canada energy relationship, where Canada has become a dominant supplier of crude oil to the US over the years (chart 1). If a 10% tariff were imposed on Canadian crude, it could result in significant economic disruption for both nations. This reliance on Canadian crude highlights critical aspects of the US energy sector. Although the US is a net exporter of refined oil, it remains heavily dependent on Canada’s heavy, sour crude, particularly for refineries in the Midwest (chart 2). Additionally, fully and immediately replacing this crucial supply is challenging for US refiners, as alternatives like Venezuelan crude are politically unfeasible and currently lack the necessary scale (chart 3).
However, what may seem disruptive to some presents a window of opportunity to others. With the recently operational Trans Mountain (TMX) pipeline, Canada has improved its access to Asian markets, and China has already begun absorbing a growing share of Canada’s crude oil output (chart 4). The competitive pricing of Canadian crude further enhances its appeal to China’s manufacturers and refiners (chart 5). While it may still be early for Canada to become a major supplier to China—given that countries from the Middle East, Russia, and Africa dominate the market—this shift signals potential for growth (chart 6).
Nonetheless, the scope and intensity of US trade actions continue to evolve. Recently-announced policy measures include a 25% tariff on all steel and aluminium imports into the US, and observers are now awaiting "reciprocal" tariffs, as promised by US President Trump, set to be revealed later this week.
The US-Canada energy relationship On February 1 this year, the United States initially announced a 10% tariff on energy imports from Canada, along with a 25% tariff on all other imports, as part of an effort to pressure Canada into addressing US concerns about illegal immigration and the flow of drugs across their shared border. In response, Canada initially announced retaliatory tariffs. However, the situation was temporarily de-escalated after a conversation between US President Trump and Canadian Prime Minister Trudeau. As part of the discussions, Trudeau agreed to ramp up security along the US-Canada border, leading to a one-month delay in the implementation of the tariffs.
This exchange between the two countries sparked widespread debate on the potential consequences of such tariffs, should they be enforced in the future. One key aspect that emerged from the discussions was the critical energy relationship between the US and Canada. Specifically, Canada’s crude oil exports to the US have become increasingly dominant over the years, as illustrated in chart 1. This growing trend underscores Canada's importance as a key supplier of crude oil to the US, highlighting the potential economic ramifications of any trade barriers between the two nations.
